A lively debate on the Reddit community r/cars recently explored a provocative question: if Porsche were to build a new sports car positioned above the iconic 911, what should it actually be? The discussion was sparked by reports that Porsche’s leadership is considering introducing a flagship sports model that would sit above the 911 in price and performance to boost profits.
For decades, the Porsche 911 has been the centerpiece of the brand’s sports-car lineup. The current generation (known as the 992) continues that tradition with a rear-engine layout and a range of powerful flat-six engines, reinforcing its status as the Stuttgart manufacturer’s most recognizable performance car.
But with competitors like Ferrari, McLaren, and Lamborghini offering ultra-expensive supercars, some enthusiasts believe Porsche could benefit from a new halo model positioned above the 911. Others argue that such a move could dilute the brand’s identity.
The Reddit thread quickly filled with hundreds of comments, ranging from serious engineering ideas to humorous suggestions. Still, several major themes emerged about what enthusiasts would like to see Porsche build next.
A Modern Hypercar or Supercar Rival
One of the most popular ideas in the discussion was for Porsche to create a new exotic supercar or hypercar, similar to the legendary Carrera GT or the hybrid 918 Spyder.
Several commenters suggested that Porsche should build a model designed to compete directly with high-end rivals such as Ferrari’s hybrid supercars or Lamborghini’s flagship models. The idea would be to create a mid-engine machine with cutting-edge technology and massive power.
Some enthusiasts proposed an eight-cylinder naturally aspirated engine, arguing that a high-revving flat-eight paired with a manual transmission would become an instant collector’s item. One commenter even described such a car as potentially “legendary” for its sound and driving experience.
Others suggested Porsche could revive design inspiration from historic racing models like the 911 GT1, which blurred the line between road car and race car in the 1990s. A modern interpretation of that concept could allow Porsche to build an extreme road-legal vehicle inspired by motorsport.
However, some users were skeptical about whether another hypercar made sense financially. Porsche’s previous halo cars were produced in extremely limited numbers and required enormous development costs. Instead, these commenters argued Porsche might prefer a high-profit supercar sold in greater numbers, rather than another ultra-rare collectible.
Still, the idea of a new technological flagship clearly excited many enthusiasts, particularly if it pushed Porsche into the same conversation as Ferrari and McLaren’s top models.
Reviving Classic Porsche Models
Another popular suggestion was to bring back historic Porsche nameplates rather than creating something entirely new.
The Porsche 928, a front-engine grand touring coupe produced from the late 1970s through the 1990s, was frequently mentioned. Some commenters argued that a modern reinterpretation could fill a niche above the 911 while offering more luxury and comfort.
Several enthusiasts imagined a two-door grand-touring car based on the Panamera platform. Such a model could use Porsche’s existing V6 or V8 engines while offering a larger interior and more practical design than the 911.
Others proposed reviving older sports-car icons like the 904 Carrera GTS, known for its lightweight construction and striking styling. A modern reinterpretation could emphasize design and exclusivity rather than outright speed.
These nostalgia-driven ideas highlight how much Porsche fans value the brand’s long history. Many commenters believed that drawing inspiration from past models could create a car that feels both fresh and authentically Porsche.
Improving the Existing Lineup Instead
Not everyone in the discussion supported the idea of a new flagship sports car. In fact, many commenters argued that Porsche should focus on improving or expanding its existing lineup instead of building something above the 911.
Some enthusiasts pointed out that the modern 911 is already incredibly fast and expensive. In their view, adding another car above it would offer little meaningful improvement in performance.
Instead, they suggested Porsche should focus on developing cars below the 911, making sports cars more accessible rather than chasing ever-higher price brackets.
One idea was to create a smaller, lighter sports car inspired by Porsche’s earliest models, such as the original 356. This vehicle could emphasize driving enjoyment rather than extreme performance.
Others suggested Porsche should enhance existing models like the Cayman or Boxster platforms by fitting them with more powerful engines or upgraded suspension systems. According to these commenters, such changes could deliver supercar-level driving dynamics without requiring an entirely new model.
There was also concern that introducing a more expensive car could undermine the 911’s status as Porsche’s ultimate road car. Some fans argued that the 911 already serves as the brand’s halo product and should remain at the top of the lineup.
A Debate That Shows Porsche’s Unique Position
The Reddit discussion ultimately revealed just how passionate enthusiasts are about Porsche’s future.
Some fans dream of an all-new supercar capable of competing with the most exotic machines on the market. Others prefer a revival of classic Porsche models that would celebrate the brand’s heritage. And a third group believes the company should simply refine its current lineup rather than creating something entirely new.
Whatever Porsche ultimately decides, one thing is clear: the idea of a sports car positioned above the 911 has sparked enormous interest among car enthusiasts. If such a model ever becomes reality, it will face enormous expectations from fans who believe Porsche’s next flagship should be nothing short of extraordinary.