“$420 FSD Mistake”: Tesla Driver Trusts Full Self-Driving on Highway, Regrets It Almost Instantly

Tesla Driver Trusts Full Self-Driving on Highway, Strikes Debris and Loses Tire Pressure Almost Instantly
Image Credit: u/Hipster-Police on Reddit

Tesla’s Full Self-Driving technology promises to make everyday driving more convenient, but unexpected road hazards can still create dangerous situations for motorists. One California Tesla Model Y owner learned this the expensive way after their vehicle struck debris on the highway while Full Self-Driving was engaged, resulting in a $421 tire replacement.

The incident was shared on Reddit’s r/TeslaModelY community by u/Hipster-Police, who described the experience in a post titled “$420 FSD Mistake.” According to the owner, their 2027 Tesla Model Y Premium RWD was traveling at 71 mph when the system drove directly over an object roughly the size of a water bottle.

Immediately after the impact, the driver heard a loud boom followed by a hissing sound, even with the vehicle’s windows closed. The tire pressure warning appeared almost instantly, with the affected tire dropping to just 1 PSI and forcing the owner to take control of the vehicle.

Making matters worse, the owner had purchased the Tesla only three weeks earlier and had been praising Full Self-Driving during a phone call just minutes before the incident. Although the driver believes they might have avoided the debris while driving manually, they acknowledged that there was little time to react and emphasized that they weren’t necessarily blaming the system.

Tesla Model Y Owner Faces $421 Tire Replacement After Highway Incident

Embedded Reddit post follows; please give it a moment to load.

$420 FSD Mistake
by
u/Hipster-Police in
TeslaModelY

 

The owner explained that the incident occurred while traveling along a Southern California freeway and approaching an exit ramp with Full Self-Driving engaged. After noticing the debris in the roadway, the driver watched the Tesla continue forward without avoiding the object, resulting in an immediate tire puncture.

With the tire rapidly losing pressure, the owner disengaged Full Self-Driving and carefully traveled approximately one-eighth of a mile to reach the exit. They explained that stopping immediately would have been difficult because the off-ramp had only one lane, leaving few safe options for pulling over.

The resulting tire replacement cost $421, an unexpected expense for someone who had owned the vehicle for less than a month. Reflecting on the experience, the owner wrote, “I think I would have avoided it if I wasn’t on FSD,” while also acknowledging that safely intervening at highway speeds would have required an extremely quick reaction.

It’s hard not to feel for the owner, especially since they had just gotten the Tesla three weeks earlier and were praising Full Self-Driving minutes before everything went wrong. At the same time, the situation raises a fair question about how much drivers can really do when something unexpected happens at highway speeds, particularly when swerving out of the way could end up causing an even bigger accident.

Tesla Owners Debate Whether Full Self-Driving Could Have Avoided the Debris

The Reddit discussion quickly turned into a debate about driver responsibility and the limitations of Tesla’s supervised driving technology. One commenter warned, “FSD is fine until it isn’t,” explaining that drivers must remain prepared to intervene whenever the system makes a mistake.

Others argued that avoiding the debris might have been difficult even with a human driver controlling the vehicle, particularly when traveling at 71 mph. One user questioned whether suddenly grabbing the steering wheel and swerving would have been safer, while another compared the situation to attempting to catch a falling knife because of the limited time available to react.

Another Tesla owner shared a similar experience, claiming that Full Self-Driving had previously damaged one of their wheels during an abrupt maneuver that happened too quickly to prevent. Despite the criticism, the original poster maintained a balanced perspective, writing, “I’m not faulting FSD, but just posting about an unfortunate situation that happened while on FSD,” highlighting the challenges of responding to unexpected highway hazards even when advanced driver-assistance technology is engaged.

Author: Nat Collazo

Nat is an extreme hobbyist who enjoys learning everything there is to know/writing about the video game industry. After graduating, they hopped into various careers, including Pre-K teacher, Marketing Manager, Copywriter, and Retail Manager, all while writing for gaming sites such as Pro Game Guides, The Nerd Stash, DailyGamer, Power Up Gaming, and Hardcore Gamer.

Stationed in the northeast, Nat spends their free time learning new skills and running a social media marketing company for indie devs!

Leave a Comment

Flipboard