Ford F-150 Owner Takes Truck to Dealership for Oil Change, Gets Hit With $17,600 Engine Bill. Who Is At Fault?

Image Credit: Ellen Buy Ford / YouTube

A Ford F-150 owner took their truck for an oil change at their local dealership, and now they are facing a hefty repair bill, leaving them questioning whether the dealership is responsible.

The owner of the truck shared the situation in a post on the r/MechanicAdvice subreddit. In the post, they explain that the truck is a 2011 model with a 5.0-liter V8 and 72,500 miles. They usually perform services like oil changes on their own and keep track of each time they do them, but they decided to take it to a dealership this time.

They said they regularly add a bottle of Liqui Moly to the engine after other Ford owners recommended it to them. According to the post, their last oil change was at around 66,731 miles.

However, things took a turn after the recent oil change, and they started hearing a metallic rattling noise whenever the truck reached speeds of around 15 to 20 mph. They brought the truck back to the dealership and had a service advisor inspect the issue, but the advisor couldn’t identify the cause.

The F-150 Needs a New Engine

Ford F150 oil change and now being told engine needs replacing
by
u/zHitmanX in
MechanicAdvice


The owner further explained that they eventually scheduled an appointment for the following morning, but the truck wouldn’t start. It would crank and almost sputter, so they had it towed to the dealership.

When it arrived at the dealership, the owner received some unexpected news: the truck needed a long-block engine replacement because of an internal issue, and they were quoted $17,600 for the repair.

The owner questioned the diagnosis, and the dealership reportedly blamed it on a lack of maintenance, the oil additive, and engine wear. They also asked the dealership whether it had measured how much oil was drained from the engine but said the shop only had a record of how much new oil its machine dispensed.

A compression test was also performed by the dealership, which reportedly came back as negative. However, the owner said they weren’t given specific cylinder readings or measurements. Now, the owner is asking others for help and wondering exactly who is at fault for the engine failure.

Who Was at Fault?

The owner also said that a manager suggested sludge inside the engine may have been disturbed when the old oil was drained. The manager also suggested that the additive could have thickened the old oil, meaning the fresh oil was thinner and potentially allowed an existing problem with a bearing or piston to develop.

Still, the dealership denied responsibility for the engine failure, leaving the owner with the $17,600 estimate.

One commenter suggested the owner get a second opinion from an independent mechanic and argued that a compression test should include actual readings. They also said the additive was unlikely to have destroyed a healthy engine.

Another commenter said that mistakes during oil changes can have major consequences, including a vehicle being returned with low oil. However, there is no evidence to suggest the dealership made that mistake.

There have been no further updates from the owner on the post, so it’s unclear whether they were able to dispute the charge or get a second opinion from another mechanic.

Leave a Comment

Flipboard