A retired Subaru owner nearly spent thousands of dollars fixing problems that apparently didn’t exist. His well-maintained 2017 Outback had developed rattling noises and highway vibrations, prompting a visit to a local dealership.
Instead of identifying the source of those symptoms, the dealership recommended replacing several major components. The owner wasn’t convinced and decided to get a second opinion before authorizing the work.
YouTube mechanic Car Wizard examined the Outback and quickly questioned the recommendations. “This older retired customer just about got taken advantage of and taken to the cleaners by the dealer again,” he said.
The Subaru had just 61,244 miles on its odometer, and its condition suggested careful ownership. As the inspection progressed, the mechanic discovered that the dealership’s proposed repairs had little to do with the owner’s complaints.
The Dealership Wanted New Hoses and Mounts

According to Car Wizard, the dealership recommended replacing all the radiator and heater hoses, along with the engine and transmission mounts. After inspecting the hoses, he found them soft and pliable despite the dust covering the engine bay. “I don’t know why they recommended that,” he said. “It does not need that at all.”
The mounts looked equally healthy underneath the vehicle, but he also tested them with the engine running. Shifting between drive and reverse produced virtually no movement.
“There’s nothing wrong with these motor mounts or the transmission mount,” he concluded. “0% wrong. They are in great shape.”
The Real Rattle Came From the Brakes

Technician Clay described the noise during a road test as sounding “like a tin can full of bolts.” The culprit turned out to be loose brake calipers caused by worn guide pins.
“The guide pins are shot,” Car Wizard explained, demonstrating how the calipers rattled when moved by hand. He noted that the problem could become particularly noticeable over small road imperfections.
The Highway Vibration Had Another Cause
The owner had also reported a persistent vibration around 65 to 70 mph. Clay confirmed that braking and steering inputs made no difference, pointing the diagnosis away from the components the dealership wanted replaced. “It’s just an out of balance tire,” Car Wizard said. “It just needs a tire balance.”
He was frustrated that the dealership hadn’t offered those simpler repairs. “Replacing parts that aren’t even bad,” he complained, adding that the original symptoms would have continued.
A Second Opinion Made the Difference
The mechanic said the owner was relieved after learning what was actually wrong. “I’m so glad that I did,” the customer told him about seeking another opinion.
The most frustrating part for Car Wizard was that the dealership could have offered the work the Subaru actually needed. As he pointed out, replacing the mounts and hoses would have left the owner with the same rattle and highway vibration, despite a potentially substantial repair bill.
