An off-duty firefighter drove a damaged SUV to the department where he works, with state troopers following.
The ISP Lowell Post reported the first impact around midnight on September 14 at the I-65/I-80 interchange in Gary, Indiana.
Trooper Garcia sat inside a marked Dodge Durango with its emergency lights activated, blocking lanes for road construction, when the SUV struck it. He was treated at Northlake Methodist Hospital for injuries described as non-life-threatening.
The SUV crossed another work zone, forcing road crews out of its path, then left the interstate at Broadway. The driver ran traffic signals along 25th Avenue and nearly hit another vehicle before stopping.
The Last Turn
Michael D. Rodriguez, 47, of Gary, was arrested.
During the arrest, he showed signs of alcohol impairment, admitted drinking before driving, and had open containers inside the SUV.
After declining field sobriety and certified chemical tests, a Lake County judge authorized a blood draw at Southlake Methodist Hospital. He was later booked into the Lake County Jail.
His preliminary charges are:
- Reckless driving in a construction zone while intoxicated, a Level 6 felony
- Leaving the scene of a serious-bodily-injury crash, a Level 6 felony
- Operating while intoxicated causing injury, a Level 6 felony
- Operating while intoxicated endangering a person, a Class A misdemeanor
- Operating while intoxicated, a Class C misdemeanor
- Reckless driving, a Class A misdemeanor
A Level 6 felony carries six months to two and a half years in prison and a possible $10,000 fine.
All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.
Off the Clock
The City of Gary and Gary Fire Department placed Rodriguez on unpaid leave pending the police investigation and an administrative review.
Fire Chief Larry Tillman told ABC7 Chicago that he was grateful Garcia was doing well and wished him a speedy recovery. Incidents involving public-safety partners, Tillman said, “hit closer to home.”
Columbus, Indiana, firefighter Nicholas Tuttle was placed on administrative leave after a 2023 off-duty crash seriously injured another driver. By his April 2024 sentencing, The Republic described him as a former firefighter. Tuttle received one year in prison followed by one year of work release.
The Cruiser Bill
An OWI or DUI charge does not automatically cancel auto liability coverage. The driver’s insurer may still pay third-party claims for injuries or damaged property up to the policy limits. Higher premiums or nonrenewal can follow afterward.
Indiana motorists must carry at least $25,000 for property damage, $25,000 for injury to one person, and $50,000 for injuries to multiple people in one crash.
Government fleets carry their own financial protection. A city, county, or state may buy commercial insurance, participate in a public risk pool, or pay smaller losses from a reserve backed by excess coverage.
The driver’s insurer can reimburse the government directly. When fleet coverage pays first, the public owner or its insurer can seek repayment through subrogation. Restitution or a civil lawsuit offers another route for recovering losses beyond the available policy limits.
Waterbury, Connecticut, used civil court after a teenager driving a stolen Volkswagen struck a marked cruiser. In 2025, the city won a judgment under the state’s parental-liability law. The award covered $6,298.61 in damage to a Ford Crown Victoria plus $708.07 in workers’ compensation payments to two officers..
