A Honda CR-V owner said on Reddit on Nov. 18 that a routine service visit turned into a pitch to buy their SUV. The one-year-old 2025 CR-V had cost them $40,000. The dealership offered $23,000.
The owner said the pitch felt pushy. They told the service advisor they’d happily buy a CR-V just like theirs from the dealership for the same $23,000. The owner described the advisor as “speechless.”
While waiting for the work to finish, the owner checked the dealership’s website. They say they found another 2025 CR-V with the same specs and just 1,000 fewer miles. The asking price was $34,990.
The listing gave the owner a way to test how far the dealership would budge on its own price. Once the work was done, they went back to the advisor with an offer of their own.
The Counteroffer
Dealership trying to buy my car
by
u/Resident-Caramel-727 in
FuckDealerships
The owner offered $25,000 for the CR-V on the lot. Their reasoning was simple. If the dealer could buy a similar Honda for $23,000, the owner figured an extra $2,000 should leave room for a deal. The advisor said no, according to the owner.
That $11,990 gap compares what the dealership offered for one SUV with what it asked for another. Kelley Blue Book says used-car asking prices reflect costs such as advertising and sales commissions and assume the vehicle has been reconditioned. The Reddit post leaves out the dealership’s name and the CR-V’s trim, two details that would help pin down the listing and judge the offer against comparable vehicles.
A second offer on the owner’s actual CR-V would make for a cleaner comparison. Even two cars with the same trim and close mileage can draw different offers if their condition or history differs.
Who Gets the Survey?
The comments turned to a question familiar to anyone who has gotten a customer survey after a service appointment. Should a sales pitch count against the people who worked on the car? One commenter argued that sales and service staff have separate jobs. Another pointed out that customers booked one appointment with one dealership, and an offer made during that visit was part of the experience.
Dealerships can use service appointments to find used cars for their lots. In an ownership study, Cox Automotive found that 14% of consumers surveyed had been offered a trade-in valuation during a service visit. Cox also advises dealers to bring up vehicle values during those appointments even when the customer hasn’t asked.
