A Reddit poster said a friend told them the car was fine to drive. They shared a close-up of the part in question in r/MechanicAdvice. Near the top of the suspension spring, a short length of rusty coil appears to have snapped off and stayed caught just below its mount.
The poster’s reason for asking was right there in the title. “Kinda expensive to fix,” they wrote. They didn’t name the car. The question was familiar to anyone who’s had to decide whether a repair could wait on a car they still need every day.
One of the most popular replies suggested the friend should swap cars with the poster and drive it around. Other commenters focused on what would happen if that short piece of steel came loose, including where it might end up on a road full of other cars.
The discussion soon turned to a second question. If the spring itself was cheap, why pay someone else to put it in? Commenters split over whether it was a job to tackle at home.
Still in Place
My friend said this ok to drive. Is he right? Kinda expensive to fix.
by
u/Consistent_Part8202 in
MechanicAdvice
A coil spring supports the car’s weight and compresses as the wheel moves over bumps. A break near the end can be easy to miss, and the car can still look level. Crown Auto Service, a repair shop in Springfield, Missouri, says a broken or displaced spring calls for a tow. A loose section can shift into a tire or fall away from the vehicle.
Manufacturers have documented both kinds of trouble. In a recall notice for certain 2011 Sonatas, Hyundai explained that a front spring could fracture from corrosion and puncture a tire. In a separate filing for certain Jeep Grand Cherokees, FCA warned that an incorrectly installed rear spring could detach while the vehicle was moving, creating a hazard for other road users.
About That Repair
Some commenters identified the part as a rear spring and said they’d consider it a simple job. “Some famous last words, right there,” another replied. The disagreement makes sense when you consider how much the job depends on the car’s suspension design and whether the spring is still under load when it comes out.
A Nissan service bulletin gives one example of what that stored force can do. It warns technicians that dropping a compressor while it’s holding a spring can send the spring flying out of the tool. Even with the proper equipment, how the spring is held matters.
The price of the spring is only one part of the bill. RepairPal’s replacement estimator shows labor can cost about as much as the part itself, and the price can rise if nearby parts also need work. The poster gave no shop quote to compare.
The thread is now locked, with no repair update from the poster in the visible discussion. For a shop looking at a break like this, the spring itself is only part of the inspection. Crown Auto Service also checks the seats that hold it and looks for contact marks or damage on the tire and nearby parts.
