Cheapest 2005 Ford Mustang GT on Facebook Marketplace Turns Into a Repair Nightmare

Image Credit: Matt McKinzie / YouTube.

A cheap Mustang can be hard to resist, especially when it’s a V8-powered GT that only needs a little work. That’s what YouTuber Matt McKinzie was hoping for when his crew picked up the cheapest 2005 Ford Mustang GT they could find on Facebook Marketplace. Unfortunately, the engine had other plans.

The seller had mentioned that the car needed some attention, but the sound coming from under the hood suggested something considerably worse. Once the crew started taking the engine apart, they discovered missing and badly damaged timing components, along with debris collecting where it absolutely didn’t belong.

Fixing the Mustang was already shaping up to be an expensive project. McKinzie estimated that roughly $4,000 in parts had been ordered, including upgrades intended to make the 4.6-liter V8 more powerful. Unfortunately, getting those parts delivered would become another adventure.

In a November 11 video on his YouTube channel, McKinzie documents a rebuild involving troublesome suppliers, a costly parts-store mistake, and enough setbacks to test anyone’s patience. Somehow, the Mustang eventually makes it back onto the road.

Things Get Ugly

Embedded media follows; please allow a moment to load.

Removing the engine’s front cover revealed a missing metal timing-chain guide and another tensioner worn completely through. Instead of controlling the chain properly, part of the tensioner was rubbing directly against it.

The crew also removed the oil pan, revealing plastic fragments lodged in the oil pickup screen. That debris could restrict oil flow, making the situation considerably more serious than a noisy timing chain.

McKinzie ordered replacement timing components, steel tensioners, a higher-pressure oil pump, and other upgrades. Ford’s service documentation confirms that the three-valve 4.6-liter engine uses hydraulically tensioned timing chains and variable camshaft timing, making proper lubrication particularly important.

Where Are The Parts?

The mechanical problems were only part of the frustration. McKinzie says he ordered approximately $800 worth of BBK ceramic-coated long-tube headers from a Tennessee supplier, but the parts never arrived.

After repeated attempts to contact the seller, he says the crew filed a bank chargeback. Meanwhile, their exhaust plans were left hanging.

Another supplier presented a similar headache. McKinzie says a Florida company accepted roughly $1,500 for camshafts and valve springs that appeared to be available immediately. Instead, he received a notice indicating delivery could take six to eight weeks.

According to McKinzie, the company explained that it was a drop-shipper and its own supplier didn’t have the parts. The crew disputed that purchase, too, and ordered replacement components elsewhere.

The Wrong Gaskets

Just when the rebuild seemed ready to move forward, an ordinary parts-store purchase caused perhaps the most aggravating setback.

The crew had installed the cylinder heads and tightened everything down using new hardware. While checking the remaining gaskets, McKinzie noticed that some exhaust gaskets didn’t fit.

Looking up the part number revealed that the local store had supplied a gasket kit for a 1999 two-valve Mustang rather than the 2005 three-valve engine.

The head gaskets looked close enough to install, but McKinzie discovered that their openings didn’t properly accommodate the newer engine’s oil passages. Running the engine that way risked damaging the camshafts and phasers.

Off came the cylinder heads again. The mistake meant buying another gasket set and replacement head bolts, with the crew having to repeat work it thought was finished.

Finally, Some Smoke

With the correct gaskets installed, the team finished assembling the engine, including its new Mutha Thumper camshafts and modified cam phasers. Because the missing headers had already disrupted their exhaust plans, they fabricated temporary connecting pipes from scrap material.

The Mustang eventually fired up, although getting it to idle properly required several hours of tuning. During an early driveway test, it stalled and lost fuel pressure. Fortunately, adding gasoline solved that particular mystery.

Once the tune was sorted, McKinzie took the Mustang out for the payoff everyone had been waiting for: a tire-smoking burnout.

The rebuilt V8 was running, and McKinzie declared it possibly the loudest car in the county. He wasn’t finished with it, either. His next plans include improving the Mustang’s appearance, changing the wheels and tires, and chasing another 100 horsepower in a second installment.

Author: Olivia Richman

Olivia Richman has been a journalist for 10 years, specializing in esports, games, cars, and all things tech. When she isn’t writing nerdy stuff, Olivia is taking her cars to the track, eating pho, and playing the Pokemon TCG.

Leave a Comment

Flipboard