A traffic stop in Nashville sent former Wild Orchid singer Stefanie Fair to jail on a DUI charge in 2024. Tennessee has now approved a $70,000 settlement over the arrest. A spokesperson for the Tennessee attorney general’s office told WSMV that the state Board of Claims had approved the agreement and payment was expected within weeks.
Tennessee Highway Patrol Trooper Keith Velez pulled Fair over on Armory Drive on June 23, 2024, for failing to move over. Fair apologized for failing to yield. The stop turned into a DUI investigation when Velez said he smelled alcohol.
“On my life, I don’t drink alcohol,” Fair said in the footage. Velez put her through field sobriety tests and noted signs he took as evidence of impairment. Fair later agreed to a blood draw, NewsChannel 5 reported.
Fair had spent part of the hour before the stop at an ice cream shop in Brentwood. Her attorney, Ben Raybin, obtained video from the shop that showed her eating ice cream. The full blood test results took about two months to come back and showed neither alcohol nor drugs.
While Fair Waited
“Not even 12 hours later, my mugshot is on Scoop Nashville,” Fair told WSMV in 2024. Her husband, Ron Fair, said a caller offered to have the image removed for $12,000. The family refused to pay.
The DUI charge was dismissed, but the Instagram post was still visible when WSMV reported on it that December. In May 2025, Fair filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against Velez.
Other Drivers Sued
The Tennessee Board of Claims previously confirmed a $75,000 settlement for Thomas Manis, who was arrested for DUI in Monroe County in 2023 and whose blood tests also came back clear. Former U.S. attorney Jane Bondurant took a separate case to federal court, suing Trooper James Zahn and three supervisors after her own DUI arrest. WSMV identified Bondurant as the eighth sober driver Zahn arrested for DUI. WSMV also reported on a Thompson Station man’s lawsuit claiming Zahn arrested him for DUI while he was sober. That case would bring the station’s count to nine.
A 2025 Tennessee law requires the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation to report annually on DUI arrests in which testing detects no alcohol or other intoxicants. Raybin told NewsChannel 5 he wants lawmakers to consider a way for drivers in cases like Fair’s to get compensation without having to sue.
