A Washington woman caused a crash that killed her three children and seriously injured her husband. Two years later, he sued her and won a $17.1 million arbitration award, despite their automobile liability insurance having a limit of just $200,000.
Nationwide paid the award and settled a separate claim from the other driver. The wife then pursued her own claims against Nationwide, ultimately winning a judgment exceeding $103 million over the company’s handling of the insurance dispute.
On November 10, 2026, the Washington Court of Appeals overturned approximately $87 million in damages while upholding findings that Nationwide acted in bad faith, was negligent, and violated Washington’s Consumer Protection Act.
Guessing Headlights reviewed the appellate opinion and the parties’ court filings, which document years of competing claims, disputed settlement decisions, and litigation between the spouses and their insurer.
The Highway Crash
On August 16, 2017, around 5:55 p.m., Meseret Shiferaw was driving an SUV west on Highway 570 near Hanna, Alberta, with her husband, Solomon Agere, and their three children. She failed to stop at a stop sign on Highway 36, entering the path of a southbound semitruck driven by Paul Coyle.
Their children, ages 16, 11, and 11 months, died at the scene. Both parents suffered serious injuries, while Coyle was also injured. Global News reported that Shiferaw was airlifted to a Calgary hospital and Agere was transported by ambulance.
The Royal Canadian Mounted Police investigated the collision, sending a reconstruction specialist to the scene. An RCMP spokesperson told CityNews Calgary that investigators were awaiting the specialist’s findings. Available records do not show whether criminal charges or traffic citations followed.
Shiferaw’s Washington-issued Nationwide policy provided bodily injury liability coverage of $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident. An out-of-state provision increased the aggregate limit to $200,000 to meet Alberta’s insurance requirements. Nationwide quickly determined that she was solely responsible for the crash and that the claims would far exceed her coverage.
The Husband Sues
Beginning in October 2017, Agere’s attorney repeatedly demanded that Nationwide settle his injury claim and the children’s wrongful death claims within the available policy limits.
Nationwide declined because Coyle also had a potential claim. Paying Agere the entire $200,000 could exhaust the coverage and end Nationwide’s defense obligations, leaving Shiferaw exposed to further litigation without an insurer-provided attorney. The company wanted to resolve all claims together, although Coyle had made no formal settlement demand.
By June 2019, the two-year limitations period was approaching. Agere’s attorney renewed his settlement demand, and Nationwide again declined, warning Shiferaw that litigation might follow.
On August 12, the attorney presented Nationwide with two options: settle within the policy limits or agree to extend the filing deadline by four months. Otherwise, Agere would have to sue his wife over his injuries and their children’s deaths or risk losing his claims.
Nationwide refused the proposed arrangement. Three days later, Agere sued Shiferaw in Spokane County Superior Court and subsequently added Nationwide as a defendant. Unknown to the insurer, Coyle had already sued Shiferaw in Alberta that May.
Shiferaw’s attorneys argued that Nationwide had failed to protect her despite knowing liability was clear and damages exceeded the coverage. Nationwide maintained that its approach was intended to protect her from competing claims. It also disputed whether the husband’s lawsuit was unavoidable, arguing that the spouses could have pursued a tolling agreement or other measures to preserve his claims.
In March 2020, Agere and Shiferaw agreed to binding arbitration and stipulated that Washington law would govern damages, interest, costs, and attorney fees. Nationwide received notice and the relevant filings and was invited to participate. An attorney representing the insurer attended by telephone but chose to observe rather than actively participate.
A Pyrrhic Award
In June 2020, the arbitrator awarded Agere and the children’s estates $17,123,927.71, including approximately $16.6 million for wrongful death and survival claims, $517,761.75 for Agere’s injuries and a small amount for costs and statutory attorney fees.
After deducting the $200,000 Nationwide had already paid, the remaining award exceeded the policy limit by more than $16 million. Nationwide agreed to pay it that August, and Agere released his claims against Shiferaw and the insurer. Nationwide also paid $145,445.26 to settle Coyle’s separate claim.
The arbitration award represented liability beyond the insurance contract, rather than an ordinary payment owed under the $200,000 policy. An insurer can face additional financial exposure if its own mishandling of claims breaches obligations to its policyholder. Nationwide maintained that paying the award protected Shiferaw from personal liability, although no court had ordered that payment under the original policy.
Resolving the claims against Shiferaw did not end her dispute with Nationwide. She continued pursuing the insurer for its earlier conduct, alleging failures to negotiate, settle, communicate, and defend the claims properly.
At a January 2023 trial, jurors heard evidence that Nationwide had made no settlement offer to Agere before he sued, failed to resolve or assist in dividing the available liability coverage for approximately two years, and should have appointed defense counsel earlier. Testimony also addressed inadequate communication, inexperienced adjusters, failures to escalate the claim internally, and the withholding of Nationwide’s claims file from an attorney assigned to defend Shiferaw.
The jury found Nationwide liable for bad faith, negligence, violations of Washington’s Consumer Protection Act, and violations of the Insurance Fair Conduct Act. Jurors awarded $27.136 million in compensatory damages, including $20 million under the Insurance Fair Conduct Act, $5 million for bad faith, $2 million for negligence, and $136,000 in economic damages.
A separate trial phase produced $47 million in punitive damages under Ohio law, which the judge applied because Nationwide was based in Ohio and made its claims decisions there. The court added another $20.136 million in enhanced statutory damages, plus attorney fees and costs.
By May 2023, the judgment totaled $103,229,771.04, separate from Nationwide’s earlier payments resolving the crash-related claims.
The Appeal
Nationwide appealed, challenging the legal basis for the damages and alleging misconduct by Shiferaw’s attorneys. Having paid more than 86 times the policy limit to resolve the underlying claims, the insurer argued that the spouses’ legal strategy had unnecessarily increased Shiferaw’s exposure.
Shiferaw’s lawyers accused Nationwide of repeatedly rejecting settlement opportunities and waiting to see whether claimants would miss their filing deadlines rather than negotiating a resolution.
The appellate judges acknowledged substantial problems with Nationwide’s claims handling, including multiyear delays, inadequate communication, inexperienced adjusters, and failure to make an early settlement offer. Those problems supported the jury’s findings of bad faith and negligence.
However, the court overturned the $47 million punitive award. Washington law governed the dispute and did not permit common-law punitive damages. Even if Ohio law had applied, the judges found insufficient evidence of actual malice, concluding that Nationwide had followed legal advice and pursued a strategy intended to protect Shiferaw from competing claims, despite its flawed execution.
The panel also reversed the Insurance Fair Conduct Act awards. Nationwide had paid the contractual $200,000 limit in February 2020, before Shiferaw filed her formal notice under that statute. The dispute concerned delayed payments to third parties rather than an unreasonable denial of contractual benefits, which the law required for her claim.
The decision eliminated $47 million in punitive damages, $20 million in compensatory damages, and $20.136 million in enhanced statutory damages. It separately vacated approximately $8.96 million in attorney fees and costs for recalculation.
Approximately $7.136 million in compensatory damages remains intact, along with the findings of bad faith, negligence, and a Consumer Protection Act violation.
Nationwide also lost its request for a new trial based on the conduct of Shiferaw’s attorneys. The appellate judges acknowledged questionable behavior by lawyers on both sides but found that the trial judge had handled the proceedings within her discretion.
The lower court must now reconsider attorney fees and Shiferaw’s request for an injunction addressing Nationwide’s claims-handling practices. In a statement to Law360, Nationwide acknowledged the family’s loss and said it welcomed the correction of errors in the original judgment.
