Car insurance has become a much bigger expense for American drivers over the past three years, and those with poor credit are being hit especially hard. Even people who haven’t had a ticket or caused a crash are seeing steep increases.
A new NerdWallet study found that premiums for drivers with poor credit rose 37.7% between January 2023 and January 2026. The increase came as insurance prices across the country climbed much faster than personal income.
By January 2026, the median annual cost of full coverage for a driver with poor credit and a clean record had reached $3,944. That works out to nearly $329 a month just to keep a vehicle insured.
The findings have frustrated drivers who believe their record behind the wheel should carry more weight than their finances. Some have questioned why years of paying insurance bills on time don’t seem to protect them from higher rates.
Drivers Aren’t Happy
Embedded media follows; please allow a moment to load.
When 2822 News shared the findings on Facebook, several readers questioned the connection between credit and driving.
One commenter, Jim Rossick, wondered why a temporary drop in credit should raise his rates when he had paid his insurance bills on time for years. Another, Randy RS, shared how medical bills and health problems had hurt his mother’s credit. He believed that contributed to her high insurance costs.
Other drivers offered different explanations for their rising bills, including uninsured motorists and crashes in their areas. The comments reflected frustration with insurance pricing and the many factors that can affect a driver’s premium.
Behind the Numbers
The problem extends beyond credit scores. NerdWallet’s 2026 Auto Insurance Rates Report found that the median premium for a driver with good credit and a clean record increased 32.3% over three years.
During that same period, per-capita personal income rose only 13%. Insurance costs grew nearly two and a half times as fast, leaving a larger share of income going toward coverage.
Several factors helped drive those increases. Modern vehicles carry costly sensors, cameras, and other parts that can make repairs expensive. Insurance claims have also become more costly to settle, even as crash numbers have fallen below pre-pandemic levels.
Location makes another difference. Minnesota recorded a 56.9% increase in premiums, followed by Iowa at 53.4% and Wisconsin at 52.8%. Severe weather and costly vehicle damage have added pressure in parts of the Midwest.
Why Credit Matters
Most states allow insurers to examine credit history when setting rates. Companies use a special insurance score, which differs from the credit scores lenders rely on.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners explains that insurers use these scores to help predict future claims. A Federal Trade Commission study also found a connection between credit-based scores and insurance risk.
Consumer advocates argue that the practice can punish people facing financial trouble, regardless of their driving habits. California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts prohibit insurers from using credit to determine auto insurance rates.
Finding a Better Deal
Despite years of higher premiums, the latest figures suggest prices may finally be stabilizing. NerdWallet found that insurance rates rose just 2.6% during the final year of its study, compared with increases exceeding 13% in each of the previous two years.
That slowdown offers little immediate comfort to drivers already facing expensive policies. Shopping around remains one of the quickest ways to find savings because insurers weigh credit and other risks differently.
One Facebook commenter urged people to compare prices at every renewal rather than remain with the same company. NerdWallet’s research suggests many drivers aren’t doing that. Just 22% of insured Americans surveyed had shopped for a new policy during the previous 12 months.
Drivers can also consider higher deductibles or review coverage on older vehicles, provided they can afford the added costs after a crash. Usage-based policies may offer savings for some motorists, though they can involve tracking driving habits.
NerdWallet found that 49% of insured Americans surveyed were stressed about their premiums. Even among households earning at least $100,000 annually, 45% reported concerns about the cost.
