A Florida buyer paid an extra $2,621 for a repair plan on a used Honda Odyssey. They say staff sold it as two years of “bumper-to-bumper” coverage. When the van needed new shocks and struts, the buyer says the dealership told them those parts were not covered.
In a Reddit post about Toyota of Melbourne, the buyer says they paid more than $20,000 for the 2020 van. They chose it to carry their wife and children and bought the extra protection through the finance office.
Less than 3,000 miles into ownership, the buyer took their complaint to the local r/321 forum. Their one-star review questions the van’s condition at sale. It also questions how staff described the plan.
“I didn’t buy a $2,000 project car off someone’s driveway,” the buyer wrote. They had gone to a dealer to buy a family van they could count on.
A Rough Start
One star review toyota of Melbourne Fl
by
u/Mammoth_Artichoke347 in
321
Trouble began three days after the purchase, when the battery died with the buyer’s children along, the post says. Toyota of Melbourne came out to jump-start the van, but the buyer later paid for and put in a new battery.
Another problem took longer to sort out. The buyer says the air filter housing had been put in backward. They blame that for about three months of poor gas mileage. Once warning lights came on, Toyota of Melbourne sent the Honda to another dealership for a fix, according to the account.
More recently, the buyer says the van pulls toward nearby lanes when it hits bumps. They say a repair shop found that both front struts would not hold a load and both rear shocks had failed.
That led the buyer back to the dealership about the Sterling protection plan. They say a representative told them it did not cover shocks or struts and refused to help with those repairs.
The Written Terms
The written terms matter here. Without the buyer’s actual agreement, the post cannot establish which parts the plan covers. It also cannot show whether the reported denial follows those terms.
The Federal Trade Commission explains that paid service plans cover the work set out in the contract. Few cover every repair, and some exclude parts worn out through normal use.
Who approves the work can also matter. A dealer may sell a plan while a separate firm decides which claims to pay. The FTC urges buyers to find out whether work needs approval before repairs start.
The FTC also urges buyers to have their own mechanic check a used car. That applies even if the dealer has checked it or sold it with repair coverage. A car’s history report does not replace that check. It may leave out faults with the car’s parts. The FTC advises getting a written report and a cost estimate for needed work before buying.
