A woman walked into a New Jersey dealership hoping to trade her Tesla Model S Plaid for a Cybertruck. The deal was nearly finished when George Saliba took a closer look at the car she was leaving behind.
Something about its matte black finish caught his eye. Within seconds, he was questioning the salesman who had agreed to take the Tesla without giving it a closer inspection.
The woman had described the car as garage-kept, but Saliba found signs of damage that could change its value. Even more troubling was the fact that she seemed unaware of some changes made to the vehicle.
What began as a routine trade-in at J&S AutoHaus soon became a lengthy inspection, a new round of negotiations, and a conversation about what her husband had done to the car.
Under The Paint
Embedded media follows; please allow a moment to load.
Saliba first noticed that the Tesla’s matte black finish was not a vinyl wrap. Someone had painted over its original glossy black color, which remained visible in parts of the car. There was also damage near the front, along with a crack in the glass roof.
The salesman, Philip, had missed those problems before working out the trade. Saliba was stunned that the car had made it this far into the deal without anyone catching them.
When he asked the customer about the paint, she explained that her husband handled much of what happened with their cars.
“I really try not to occupy my brain with the things that my husband does with the car,” she told him.
She knew her husband liked having vehicles wrapped, but this Tesla was different. The woman also appeared surprised when Saliba showed her the cracked roof.
A full repaint raised concerns about possible past damage. Saliba explained that he wanted to inspect the underside before agreeing to take the car, although he had no proof that it had been wrecked.
A Lower Offer
The unexpected condition problems forced the dealership to reconsider its numbers. Saliba initially discussed valuing the Tesla at $50,000, though he wanted to preserve the Cybertruck sale.
He told his staff they could offer $58,000 instead, pending a closer inspection. That would require the customer to put more money toward her purchase than originally planned.
The 2023 Model S Plaid had roughly 13,000 miles, according to the discussion in the video. Despite its relatively low mileage, Saliba was concerned about how the repaint and damaged roof might affect its resale value.
Meanwhile, the customer called her husband to discuss the revised terms. She expressed frustration about having dealt with several cars she did not want and believed had cost too much.
With the trade still undecided, the dealership moved the Tesla onto a lift.
One Last Check
Underneath, the employees spotted missing bolts, rocks, and green markings that prompted more questions. At one point, they wondered whether the Tesla had been in a crash or even suffered flood damage.
Neither possibility was confirmed. The green markings were especially puzzling until the team compared them with another Tesla and found similar markings underneath.
Saliba later said the markings were factory-applied, according to information he received during the inspection. He also reported that the trade-in had no accident history and that the dealership was satisfied with its condition.
The customer ultimately bought the Cybertruck, and J&S AutoHaus accepted the Model S Plaid after renegotiating the deal. Saliba did not disclose the final trade allowance in his closing remarks.
He placed responsibility for the initial mistake on Philip, who had failed to catch the repaint and cracked roof before the paperwork moved forward. Even with the sale saved, Saliba made clear that future trade-ins needed a much closer look before the dealership agreed on a price.
